Mickey Seacrest is the host of American Idol Mario Edition. As the series went on, it is revealed Mickey Seacrest was not the real host, but he continues to return (in hiding from an angry Mr. Pig).
Although it is unknown what happened to him after his disappearance from the series, but it can be assumed he was arrested because he faked being a host on national television. He was mentioned years later on American Idol: Season 2, Episode 1
The Mickey Seacrest character make an obvious pun off of real-life American Idol host, Ryan Seacrest.
He has never appeared in any new episodes. It is most likely that Logan lost the plush,or it has been sold somewhere.